Dec 21 2009
On Celebrating Christmas…
Potential Spoilers Ahead Concerning Santa Claus, The Easter Bunny, and Maybe Even The Tooth Fairy…be forewarned.
I find it interesting that people, who on a regular basis don’t bother with the Lord Jesus Christ, suddenly shift into being radical Christians when it comes to the “reason for the season”. I don’t have a problem with it, necessarily. It doesn’t actually affect me when people attempt to “put the Christ back in Christmas”. In my mind, He never really left it, despite what many liberals seem to desire. Ultimately, Christ will not be defeated by liberals. That’s not why I wrote, though.
I’ve been thinking a lot about whether or not Christians ought to celebrate Christmas, and more to the point what aspects of Christmas we should celebrate. My mental meanderings have a point, in that I am wondering what we should emphasize and tell my son as he grows up. What do we want to teach him, and should cultural icons be an emphasis? I have to admit that among all the things I considered teaching my children, whether or not to emphasize or ignore Santa Claus never really entered my mind.
To begin, we all know that Jesus of Nazareth was most likely NOT born on December 25th, right? I’ve heard many theories as to why this date was chosen for Christmas, from pagan goddess worship, to a feast for Bacchus (the Roman god of wine and intoxication), to a sun-worship festival, etc. Of course, December 25th is very near the Winter Solstice (which was today in the Northern Hemisphere, by the way), and the winter solstice certainly would have been a commonly celebrated festival time in pagan areas. Whichever event you favor, it’s likely a more plausible reason for the choice of December 25th to remember the birth of Christ than the actual birth of Christ.
I’m sure I don’t need to tell people that it was extremely common in the early church for missionaries to appropriate pagan festivals in order to begin where the people celebrated to teach the Gospel. Many early church fathers felt that the celebration of the Christ Mass on December 25th was adulterating the church, and should not be so. The question should be asked, however, does it matter what day Christ was actually born?
My short answer is “no”. The need for Christ to come is demonstrated by our sin, and His birth was certainly necessary. Commemorating the incarnation of Christ with a celebration is certainly not out of line, and can be used to teach our children many things about Christ and our need for Him. However, the coming of Christ is often celebrated more assiduously than the day commemorating His death and resurrection (today called Easter), which certainly seems to me to be a little backwards. Christ was born, sure. But it is not His coming that frees His people from the bondage of sin. It is His active obedience and resurrection that saves His people from their sins. But I digress…
What about the cultural decorations and trappings? Santa Claus? The Christmas Tree? Gifts? One can spiritualize it all, to be sure. I see nothing wrong with putting up a pretty tree and decorating it with colorful ornaments and lights. God is the Father of Lights, and every good and perfect gift comes from Him, we are told in the Scriptures. Salvation is certainly a free gift to any who would trust in Christ, and while our gifts pale in comparison to what our Savior paid for what He freely gives His people, we can use the gifts we give to point to Christ. The Gospel never fades…never loses its luster or relevance. Mankind is always in need of salvation. The Good News is…dare I say it…evergreen, is it not? One can spiritualize anything, if one looks hard enough, as I said.
What about Santa Claus? My thinking on this might change someday, but I think Santa Claus is one tradition that we will not be passing on to Iain. A harmless story, a fable, a pain-free deception…harming no one? Well, it is a deception, for one. I don’t really see a point. Everyone eventually learns that Santa Claus is not real. (I did warn against spoilers above.) What is the point of deception? Fun? I’m all for fun, but I would like to teach my son gratitude and appreciation for the gifts he’s been given by family and friends. I would like that appreciation and gratitude to be directed accurately. The more I think about it, the whole folklore surrounding Santa Claus (he sees you when you’re sleeping…he knows when you’re awake…he knows if you’ve been bad or good) is ascribing qualities to something not God which only belong to God. Essentially, we’re creating an idol, and venerating it for its omniscient and omnipresent powers. Now…adults don’t believe in Santa, but what are we doing to our kids? Are they more interested in getting to know Jesus, or more interested in their letter to Santa Claus? Are they more interested in pleasing the God of their Creation or in being good so Santa doesn’t bring them a lump of coal?
Another teachable thought is the fact that Nicholas of Myra (known as Saint Nicholas) was a real Bishop in the Church, who apparently participated in the Nicene Council of the Church (and even more interestingly got into a scuffle with a fellow Bishop who wanted to deny the deity of Christ at said council), and who had a penchant for gift-giving. Looking at the examples of godly men who have gone before is definitely a worthwhile pursuit, and to my thinking infinitely preferable to raising a godly man on a pedestal, giving him attributes which belong to God alone.
What about Iain ruining other kids’ fun? Well, I plan to teach Iain that people enjoy believing in Santa Claus as a game, but that he’s to respect others and not attempt to spoil their fun. (At least, provide spoilers for them, as this author has done.) ;)
I’m not really interested in arguing whether or not I believe a fairy tale as ephemeral as Santa, himself, in the person of Jesus Christ. I’ve had that discussion time and time again. If that’s your only purpose in commenting on this post, save it. Go name-call somewhere else. Accept that you just wasted however much time reading this post, and say “that’s X minutes of my life I’ll never get back.” If, however, you’re interested in discussing whether I’m overreacting as a parent or potentially damaging my son, that is an interesting discussion. I just can’t see how it’s not a lie, how it’s not disrespectful of Christ and His sacrifice, of God and His attributes, and of my son. Harmless fun, I’m down for. The enjoyments of the simple things the Lord has graciously gifted us, I’m a fan of. Teaching my son of the love and sacrifice of Christ, I am looking forward to. In the end, however, I just don’t see the loss of Santa Claus in our house as…well…a loss.
(Not that I feel I need this disclaimer, but I might as well throw it up there. I am not looking down upon, criticizing, or otherwise frowning upon parents who do the whole Santa Claus thing. Up until recently, I figured I’d do the same, and only recent, careful reflection and discussions with godly men has convinced me that my energies might be better spent elsewhere in raising MY child. I capitalize “MY” there, because I am not attempting to convince everyone that they should do the same. This post is something I’ve been wanting to write to provoke thought. If you read it, and you decide that you plan to or will continue to do the whole Santa thing, I can say nothing about it. So don’t be offended at this post, thinking that I’m commenting on anyone else’s job as a parent. My parents did the whole Santa thing, and I am not the worse for it. I have a different focus than they did, and that’s really all there is to it.)

