Jan 30 2006
A difficult question…
For me, this question is academic. The situation described is not one I face, but someone faces it…someone I know…someone I care about. So while I ask this question because I’m genuinely curious, I’m not trying to belittle the very difficult decision that someone else faces…this situation is one that no one wants to be put in. But sometimes God puts people in situations where they don’t want to be, and they have to ask themselves, “What is right?”
Obviously, to answer this question, you have to come up with some standard of what defines “rightness”, for lack of a better term. I will state up front that I am not interested in many definitions of rightness. Ethics change with the person, quite often, and even if you determine that there is an objective standard for ethics, how did you come up with that standard. Even morally right is rather ambiguous. I’m interested in what the Bible says is right. I’m not here to argue that point…I am here, however, to discuss interpretations of the Bible.
Here’s the situation. John and Jane try to get pregnant, and they are successful. However, during subsequent tests, it is ascertained that the baby has no hands or forearms. When the baby is born, they determine that there is a heart condition. Later, they determine that the baby has no sight and no hearing, and most likely there will be some mental retardation. The baby needs a cardiac surgery in order to survive…what do these parents do???
Many people would say the parents should have had an abortion before the birth…this is not an option for these parents. They are Christians, and correctly believe that abortion is evil per the Word of God. I agree with them…so does God…that answer is not an option, and in any case, does not bear any relevance to the question at hand. What do they do from here??
Well, the options are rather limited…I figure at this point, they can either spring for the cardiac surgery, affording the child some sort of future existence, though the quality and/or quantity of that existence could be called into question. Or, they can not have the sugery performed, cutting short the child’s quantity of life.
I could postulate a lot of things, but I don’t have the answers. Not performing the surgery is not the same as having an abortion…is it? Thou shalt not murder, of course, but is a lack of action the same as an evil action? Sins of omission are just as wrong as sins of comission…that, too must be considered. Should have, could have, would have’s abound…what do they do? Do they judge the fact that the child’s quantity of life will be so diminished so as to determine for her that it’s not worth living? I worked at a camp for handicapped people, and let me say that though many people would have said that their parents should have ended their existences, they have a different standard by which they judge their quality of life. I saw some miraculous things at that camp, that year, and I don’t feel that we’re qualified to judge the quality of life of any other being.
That’s the altruist in me…listen to him, for he’s often silent, as my friends will attest. But put yourself in the position of this child. No sight…no hearing. If the nervous condition that has taken her sight and hearing is bad enough, her smell and touch could be affected. She has no way to bond with the world around her…no way to receive love from her parents, possibly. No idea who her parents are, maybe…no idea WHAT parents are. I can’t wrap my puny mind around it.
I said in a recent blog that we are not equipped to deal with that with which we are not to deal…if we’re not in the situation, then God does not give us the wisdom to say how we should cope or react…or decide. I don’t have the answers, and unless you are God, or this couple, I don’t think you do either. Why post this?? It’s on my mind. It’s made me look at my quality of life…it’s made me look at the life I take for granted. Maybe it will do the same for you.
Or maybe…just maybe, you are the couple whom I have described. Maybe you are facing this situation with your little girl. I cannot help you, my loved ones. I cannot offer any insight to your situation. I am lost, with regards to this problem. But Kim and I will be praying for you, and God knows what you are going through. And through Him Who strengthens you, you can do all things. Even this. I can hug you, and my cotton shirt can absorb your tears, for tears are warranted in the tradition of He who cried for the lost of this world.
Heavenly Father…you know of whom I write about in this blog entry. I don’t even know what to ask for on their behalf. Strength to face the day. Diligence to seek out Your Word. Courage to do what they believe You want them to do. All of these things and more. Father put their hearts at peace regarding what they must do. Father prepare the hearts of those who have far more contact than I do with them. Please help them to not break the bent reed, and snuff out the dimly burning candle. Help them to be the comforters that these lovely people need. Lord, please give them wisdom to apply Your Word to their present situation, and give them peace. Father, all of this I ask in Your Holy Name. Amen.

